Peanut Butter Fruit and Compulsive Tree Shopping

When we first moved into the house, me and Mr. Pikko took turns buying trees we wanted or thought were cool. In the end we had a lime, a Meyer lemon, a mountain apple (from my dad), an orange, a jaboticaba, a pomegranate, bananas, and a peanut butter fruit tree.

The reason he bought the peanut butter tree was because Baby Girl can’t eat any nuts due to her being allergic to cashews. She used to love peanut butter toast in the morning so he thought it would be nice for her to at least have something that tastes like peanut butter.

Peanut Butter Fruit

It took two freaking years for the tree to get big enough to bear fruit, so he picked some and at last we got to taste what we’d only been thinking about. They’re pretty small but it’s hard to tell from that photo, so here’s another for scale.

Peanut Butter Fruit

He read you’re supposed to pick them as soon as they turn orange and since I just happened to notice them by chance, we’re not sure how long they were on the tree. We tried them and weren’t too impressed. The flesh was so hard it was almost nutty in not only flavor, but texture too. There wasn’t much to eat for each fruit either.

Cut Open

The photo’s a bit blurry but you can see what it looks like. Kind of like a teeny tiny papaya with a single seed. Maybe when they’re first ripe they’re softer. I read on Wikipedia that people make jams out of this stuff, but I’m not sure I understand how.

The only thing I do know is that they really do taste like peanut butter! That part at least didn’t disappoint. Still, it’s disappointing in general having had to wait 2 years for it to fruit and then to have it just be a mediocre thing. Sort of like how my pomegranate tree continues to suck, with the fruit rotting before they ripen.

I think in this case, we should have tried a fruit somehow before we bought the tree…

6 thoughts on “Peanut Butter Fruit and Compulsive Tree Shopping”

  1. If you can make a jam out of it.. pb&j sandwich all in one? Milkshake? Maybe these were on the tree too long… interesting tree though, I didn’t even know these existed.

  2. I’m so glad to see more people growing this tree and describing what they thought it tasted like. I’m planning on buying one this spring (but a larger one, so I don’t have to wait too long) and am excited to see that more people agree on the flavor. It is true though, you’re supposed to wait til the flesh is soft. It’s said to have the identical texture to peanut butter along with the taste.

Leave a Comment

Share This


Join my newsletter and get my free ecourse on dialogue punctuation!